|

General Comments

4 general comments

  1. I am trying to take notes for testing/essay purposes and find some topics hard to follow. For me, I’m trying to put things in date perspective as the chapters seem to jump around. For example, one paragraph might refer to something in the 1500’s but it is hard to know if the next paragraph is in that same time or some other time. For us detailed folks, it would be nice to have date references more often or be assured that everthing listed between date references apply to the last stated time frame.

    Thanks for your consideration.

  2. I don’t see a place for American Yawp Reader problems so I’ll post this here.

    The following seems to be titled wrong:

    harriet-h-robinson-describes-a-mill-workers-strike-1863

    The strike being referenced is from 1836. And the text was published in 1898. So unless we know that Robinson’s recollection dates to 1863, I’m thinking that the title just reversed the final two numbers in the date.

  3. Hiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii hugs

  4. Watson Jennison April 18, 2025 at 5:50 pm

    Hi. I wanted to let you know that the labeling for the “Cato Letter and Petition” document in Chapter 7 is misattributed to Freedom’s Journal, the first black newspaper in the U.S. The document is from 1781, but the newspaper did not begin publishing until 1827.

    The elimination of slavery in northern states like Pennsylvania was slow and hard-fought. A bill passed in 1780 began the slow process of eroding slavery in the state, but a proposal just one year later would have erased that bill and furthered the distance between slavery and freedom. The action of Black Philadelphians and others succeeded in defeating this measure. In this letter to the Black newspaper, Philadelphia Freedom’s Journal, a formerly enslaved man uses the rhetoric of the American Revolution to attack American slavery.

    More than likely, this document is from The Freeman’s Journal, a different Philadelphia paper published by F. Bailey between 1781 and 1792.

    Best,

    Watson

     

Leave a Comment

Your details




Your comment

Source: http://www.americanyawp.com/feedback_2017-2018/general-comments/